... A FORUM TO STIMULATE DEBATE ... ... JUST ADD A COMMENT AT ANY ENTRY BELOW... ... FOR THE SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT OF TOWN AND VALLEY ...

Monday 20 May 2019

Brexit: and failing to introduce transparency in social media advertising

The likes of Facebook and Google pretty much control what we see and do on-line:
Futures Forum: "Guided democracy" and the century of spin
Futures Forum: How to rescue our time from the digital giants

A problem being that a lot of this is not exactly transparent:
Futures Forum: Campaign to get social media to counter fake news 
Futures Forum: Brexit: and the EU elections: countering fake news from WhatsApp

And earlier this year, the government tried to push for a little more transparency: 

The UK government has called on the competition watchdog to launch an inquiry into the UK's digital ad market, specifically to probe the dominance of the Facebook-Google duopoly. UK chancellor Philip Hammond has requested that the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) launch a review after an independent report he commissioned detailed how the UK's competition framework isn't fit for the economic challenges posed by digital markets, at home and internationally. Led by Jason Furman, Barack Obama’s chief economic adviser, an independent panel of experts found that the digital advertising market "is dominated by two players and suffers from a lack of transparency".

UK government to probe dupoly's digital ad dominance | The Drum

Whether the UK government will push for a little more transparency over current uses and abuses: 

MIC WRIGHT: Efforts to introduce transparency in online political advertising are falling short

PUBLISHED: 10:00 10 May 2019 | UPDATED: 13:55 10 May 2019

Mic Wright

MIC WRIGHT says that political campaigners are undermining the democratic process with manipulative, duplicitous online advertising and more needs to be done to introduce transparency.

There was great fanfare in October 2018, when Facebook introduced new rules for political advertising running on its platform in the UK. Requiring advertisers to prove their identity and location before their messages were shown and displaying the group behind each ad to users, along with the introduction of a searchable Ad Library, was repeatedly hailed as "transparent" in media reports.

But taking a look at any one of the current Facebook ads focused on Brexit reveals how the social media giant didn't so much install a window into the world of online political advertising as opt for some frosted glass.

Messages promoted by groups with names like Better Brexit, Now Brexit and the Brexit Defence Force are linked to pages with no indication of the individuals managing them nor of their ultimate funding sources. Facebook also remains reticent to show the targeting criteria used by the advertisers. So, while it's possible to view them in the Ad Library there is no way of knowing who is seeing these messages in their Facebook newsfeeds.

The Guardian reported in April that the Mainstream Network - an operation designed to look like a grassroots campaign made up of pro-Brexit Facebook pages backing a no-deal exit - is in fact overseen by Lynton Crosby's political lobbying firm CTF Partners, with a budget of more than £1 million.

The UK information commissioner, Elizabeth Denham, told the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Sub-Committee on Disinformation that the activity is being probed as part of her office's wider investigation into the use of political data online.

Denham told MPs that she was shocked to see that the government's recent White Paper on online harms did not significantly address the issue of political advertising: "I was surprised and disappointed that there wasn't more focus on what I think is a huge societal harm, which is around electoral interference and the need for more transparency in political advertising."

The information commissioner was asked by MPs whether Facebook's changes to its rules around political advertising go far enough. She told them: "You can't leave it to an individual company. There needs to be more robust transparency tools and there needs to be regulation that requires companies to have systems in place to give real transparency."

Her view is echoed by the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (IPA) and the independent fact-checking charity FullFact, which have both called for an industry-owned register of political advertising in the UK, with details not only of content, but of who is being targeted and how much is being spent to reach them.

While Facebook's Ad Library and other measures are clearly inadequate, Twitter and Google have yet to provide public archives of UK political advertising run on their platforms.

Current rules on electoral advertising were drafted to cover posters, billboards and leaflets, not micro-targeted social media posts and customised email campaigns. The Electoral Reform Society's director of research and policy, Jess Garland, put it succinctly: "The UK's analogue-age election rules are a meddlers' charter that leave our elections vulnerable."

While the claims made in commercials for washing powder or cosmetics can be rigorously challenged by the Advertising Standard Agency (ASA), since 1997, it hasn't regulated any form of political messaging. Lies that would be unacceptable in the process of trying to sell pet food go unchallenged when it is voters being served up rhetoric to swallow. It was easier to get away with falsely claiming that Turkey was joining the EU than it is to lie about the nutritional content of a turkey drumstick.

The official Vote Leave campaign spent more than £2.7 million on targeted Facebook ads during the EU referendum. Data subsequently released by the social network to the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Sub-Committee as part of its inquiry into fake news, revealed that Vote Leave had run ads with 1,433 different messages.

They ranged from bizarre claims that the EU was out to kill the British cuppa to emotional appeals featuring polar bears and bullfighting. The adverts were seen more than 169 million times in total.

As well as relatively straightforward adverts, Vote Leave ran a competition offering a £50 million pound prize to anyone who could predict the outcome of every match played in the 2016 European championships. It was a data harvesting exercise.

But while regulators are trying to get to grips with the online political advertising equivalent of muskets, campaigners already have machine guns and tanks at their disposal.

In 2016, the Trump campaign tested an average of 50,000 ad variations a day to micro-target voters, peaking at 150,000 ads on some days. It did that, in part, by using machine learning to quickly get rid of under-performing messages and formats and bring the most effective lines to the top. Voter profiles are ever more detailed and machine learning is increasingly making connections between data sets that human campaign strategists would never be able to make on their own.

We are not far from a time when it will be possible to quickly and effectively target single voters with messaging geared to their particular hopes and fears.

A recent Channel 4 investigation accused the Arron Banks-funded Leave.EU campaign of faking footage of migrants entering the UK and attacking women, but future political advertising could make even that look mild. Deepfake videos - clips using machine learning to turn real people into convincing puppets for words or actions they might otherwise never say - are becoming increasingly advanced. It is only a matter of time before deepfakes are effectively used for political disinformation and the waters are further muddied.

Last September, three members of Congress - Democrats Adam Schiff and Stephanie Murphy, along with Republican Carlos Curbelo - wrote to the US director of national security, Dan Coats, to warn that "as deepfake technology becomes more advanced and more accessible, it could pose a threat to public discourse and national security".

The issue is not just that campaigns could use deepfake techniques to spread rumour and gossip, but that an increased climate of distrust could make it easier to discredit real videos with plausible deniability.

Donald Trump initially apologised for his comments on the infamous Access Hollywoodtapes, but he later suggested that the audio was fake. In a climate where deepfake attacks on politicians become common that kind of obfuscation will become easier for figures who are so willing to brazenly lie about their words and actions.

Currently, the UK is in a situation where the Electoral Commission complains of campaigns submitting invoices for Facebook advertising that "[make] it difficult or impossible to know what the money was spent on and where". While the regulations don't even require that minimal meaningful level of disclosure, and technology companies are not forced to deliver true transparency, the integrity of UK elections will be in doubt.

Ensuring that all online political advertising in the UK has to abide by the same imprint laws as offline advertising is key - they must state who paid for them and published them. But it has to go further than that. We need a publicly viewable algorithmic ingredient list tied to every targeted online political ad - who is seeing this message and what criteria were used to decide that they would? Revealing the recipe shouldn't be left to the whim of individual companies, but a legal requirement.

Political campaigns used to have to shout their messages but Vote Leave's targeted Facebook ads during the EU referendum were whispers. The manipulation would have been far less effective if it had been done in the full light of public scrutiny, where the conflicting tones and disparate imagery would have been apparent. It's easy to sell a lie if only people who don't know any better can hear you telling it.

This is a Wizard of Oz problem: It's currently too hard to know who is behind the curtain, pulling the strings. If voters are able to see how they are defined by campaigns that target them, they may be a lot less willing to take the messages presented to them at face value. Offline political adverts are restricted by their context, jumbled on the doormat with bills and junk mail, or pasted on a billboard.

Online, the political messaging can hide itself as a plea to defend the polar bears or ban bullfighting, while its creators have another agenda entirely. We need regulations and regulators with the power to pull back the curtain and reveal the levers, who's pulling them and who is ultimately paying for it all.


Brexit: Efforts to introduce transparency in social media advertising are failing | Latest Brexit news and top stories - The New European
.
.
.

19 comments:

Qbicocoworking said...

Work where you want, whenever you want! Our Office Space Sharing
is perfect for someone who doesn’t find the need for a physical space. You can easily place your business on-board with a prestigious work address and a virtual receptionist at your service. Our virtual offices have articulate associates who understand your business, routing calls back to you. The best part is, ZERO capital investment for your start-up.

Alex James said...

Social media use is increasing day by day in every field. Some in a good sense some in a negative sense. But social media is the best part to spread the news easily among the people who are not active on a TV news channel.

James Charlie said...

Your post definitely hits the right spot. Kudos for the hard work. Your suggestion to opt for a reliable online assignment help facility is definitely a practical and feasible one in today's scenario. This is where the impeccable online assignment help service by the MyAssignmentHelpAU platform comes into the picture. If you are looking for a comprehensive assignment help facility that caters to all your writing requirements efficiently. Their University Assignment Help service is definitely the one-stop service for you. You can easily place an order for your complicated academic assignments with the MyAssignmentHelpAU platform in three simple steps that too at highly reasonable prices.

Anonymous said...

You are doing a very good thing by spreading knowledge. Let me give you some advice benefits of a project management master thesis topic that could help you clear your business ideas about this domain.

John Hardy said...

You doing very good work. I really love your well written article. I really got a lot of information in this article. Thanks for sharing this one. Now it's time to avail african gowns for ladies for more information.

Jonny Dave said...

Social media advertising helps a lot of small businesses to gain sales. Thanks for sharing detailed information on Social media advertising. It will help me a lot. Now it's time to avail taxi milwaukee for more information.

Daisy Jones said...

I visited the link you provided and read your article on Brexit's impact on introducing new technologies. I have to say, it was an engaging and informative read! As an aspiring marketer, I was thrilled to come across your blog post about the
marketing dissertation writing service. you offer. It's not easy to find reliable and professional help in the world of academic writing, especially when it comes to such an important project like a dissertation.

Daniel Oscar said...

You have shared a very informative article with us and I am really inspired by your article writing skills. Keep sharing more article with us. Now read more about affordable value added tax services in dubai for more information.

Manitha Jones said...

Brexit has highlighted the significance of transparency in various sectors. Addressing this, social media advertising, an influential tool, requires greater transparency. Connecting this to How Many Types of Essay , there are many forms of essays. Just as Brexit reveals complexities, essays like explanatory, argumentative, and descriptive serve unique purposes. Both Brexit's transparency lessons and diverse essay types underscore the need for clarity and understanding in complex matters.

Lawrence Jonish said...

Brexit's impact on failing to introduce transparency in social media advertising highlights the urgency of addressing digital misinformation. What is CIPD Level 7 certificate equivalent to a postgraduate degree, equips professionals with advanced HR and L&D expertise, crucial for navigating complex issues like this in the evolving business landscape.

Mark Jones said...

Brexit has highlighted the critical need for transparency in social media advertising. Unfortunately, the efforts to introduce such transparency have fallen short. This issue is reminiscent of the challenges faced when searching for reliable sources, much like seeking an APA style generator to ensure accurate citations. Just as transparency in political decisions is crucial, ensuring trustworthy tools for academic integrity remains essential.

Fly High Abroad said...

Fly High Abroad is a leading skilled immigration consultant in Abu Dhabi, UAE, dedicated to helping individuals and families obtain the necessary visas and permits to live and work in UK. Our experienced team of consultants provides comprehensive services, including eligibility assessment, visa application assistance, and ongoing support throughout the immigration process.

Michael Findley said...

Brexit has showcased a significant need for a critical analysis of stakeholder engagement , particularly concerning transparency in social media advertising. To address the complex challenges of today's digital landscape, it's crucial to engage all stakeholders and critically evaluate the impact of opaque advertising practices, ensuring a more informed and democratic decision-making process.

sing along songs said...

Music has the remarkable ability to transcend language, culture, and time. It connects people in ways that few other forms of expression can. One of the most joyful experiences is singing along to your favorite songs.

Randy Suessmetz said...

The Daily Guides cover a wide range of topics worldwide. such as giving the e-readers squad high-quality content.
The blogs and articles that we permit are full of expertise and insights. Beyond that, our online publication has all recent developments facts, either comprehensive and succinct, on the world's principal subject. The energetic people who bring us news and counsel do so cautiously, managing statistics phase via the start to the conclusion.

Markcasiol said...

I checked out the link you shared and read your article about Brexit's impact on new technologies. It was interesting and helpful! As a phd student, I was happy to find your blog post about the marketing you offer. It's tough to find good phd thesis help for academic writing, especially for important projects like a dissertation and thesis. Your blog is a great resource, and I'm excited to read more.

WilliamJones said...

The way that businesses engage with their target audience has definitely been revolutionized by social media advertising. Because of its dynamic content delivery and precision targeting, it has become a vital tool for marketers. I'm interested in how the sports industry and this advertising landscape interact because I'm looking into sport management thesis topics. Research and exploration in the field have exciting new opportunities due to the potential to engage sports enthusiasts through strategic social media campaigns.

Unknown said...

In the engaging realm of FuturesForumVGS where insightful discussions pave the way for future visions and aspirations, the narrative extends beyond intellectual exchanges to consider the practicalities that facilitate seamless participation. As participants at FuturesForumVGS delve into conversations shaping tomorrow's landscapes, the significance of convenient and efficient transportation becomes evident. Recognizing the need for a fluid transition from ideas to action, the forum acknowledges the importance of door-to-door transport services. These services ensure that attendees, armed with innovative thoughts and a shared vision for the future, can seamlessly navigate the physical journey from their doorstep to the forum venue. By incorporating the door to door transport into its narrative, FuturesForumVGS underscores the commitment to a holistic experience, where the exchange of ideas is complemented by a reliable and accessible transportation solution, fostering a collaborative environment for shaping the future.





Rosa Lewis said...

Seeing the continued difficulties with Brexit and the continuous inability to introduce openness to social media advertising is depressing. To make matters worse, there are no clear rules or accountability measures in place. Transparency in advertising is even more important in a world where knowledge equals power. It makes me think of the complexity that
sci fi story writing. explore when creating futuristic societies and watching them struggle with the fallout from unbridled power and manipulation.