... A FORUM TO STIMULATE DEBATE ... ... JUST ADD A COMMENT AT ANY ENTRY BELOW... ... FOR THE SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT OF TOWN AND VALLEY ...

Friday, 3 May 2019

BREAKING NEWS: "Bad day" for the Tories as Independents in East Devon gain an overall majority of two

An extraordinary day in Devon:
England local elections 2019: Devon - BBC News 

And particularly in East Devon:
East Devon Elections results 2019 - Live - eastdevon.gov 
Live updates as East Devon District Council elections take place - Devon Live 

With the final results from the Herald's website - and a handy graphic: 




East Devon Elections 2019: Results LIVE 

For Sidmouth in particular:
Little change to Sidmouth's political landscape following district council elections 

The count for the Town Council will happen tomorrow
https://twitter.com/hashtag/eastdevonvotes?src=hash
.
.
.

Climate change: "it is possible to reduce emissions while also growing the economy”

System change?
Futures Forum: Climate change: the book 'Losing Earth' ends with a full-throated, fire-and-brimstone indictment of the carbon lobby and its ongoing denial and delaying tactics

Or being entrepreneurial?
Futures Forum: Cutting CO2 vs "Make Cars Great Again"
Futures Forum: "How doing business sustainably can actually improve the bottom line."

It is after all a matter of how you see things:
Futures Forum: Are we running out of resources?
Futures Forum: Are things actually getting better?

Hugo Swire, MP for East Devon, thinks we can get through this with a little more ingenuity:
Climate change answer is in the markets and human ingenuity | Hugo Swire

Here is his piece in the Herald:

'Climate change answer is in the markets and human ingenuity'

PUBLISHED: 17:25 29 April 2019

Daniel Wilkins

Extinction rebellion protestors are right, but the solution is in ‘cleverly’ regulated markets, according to East Devon’s MP.

In his latest column, Sir Hugo Swire agrees with activists about the reality of climate change but says it is up to 'human ingenuity' in the markets to make modern industry 'part of the equation'.

He said: “The extinction rebellion protests are telling us some inconvenient truths, which of course we already know, the reality of climate change.

“But to meet their demands would involve a mobilisation of people and resources on an unprecedented scale. It would require the state to ration air travel, replace every gas boiler in the land and borrow vast sums of money to invest in wind and solar power as well as new technologies to capture what remaining carbon we would produce.

“Where I depart with the Extinction Rebellion protesters is trying to turn the clock back on technology and asking people to stop living modern lives.

“For us to solve this crisis, it is more realistic to make modern industry part of the equation. Of course Government intervention and raising awareness has a role to play but the vital component has to be human ingenuity fostered within markets regulated cleverly by the state. And it is only in healthy, entrepreneurial economies that inventions can be made – the electric vehicles, smart electricity grids, revolutionised batteries.

“Shell, for example, has spruced up its act and is now one of the biggest investors in renewable energy in the world, spending billions on solar research and development. We need to see other big corporations following suit and to meet UN targets by 2030 or 2050 the real change has to come from industry in China, India and USA.

“Although there is still so much more to do I am proud that more than £52 billion has been invested in renewable energy in the UK, and thanks to this investment and our reforms, greenhouse gas emissions have fallen by a quarter since 2010, proving the point that it is possible to reduce emissions while also growing the economy.”


Climate change: East Devon MP says the answer is in the markets and 'human ingenuity' | Latest Sidmouth and Ottery News - Sidmouth Herald
.
.
.

Thursday, 2 May 2019

Your vote matters: vote today!

The temptation is not to vote - as a protest against a rigged system:
Futures Forum: DON'T VOTE!

Which is quite understandable, considering the last big vote:
Futures Forum: Brexit/Bremain >>> VOTE!

And considering what we think of politics and politicians:
Futures Forum: VOTE/DON'T VOTE: politicians and psychopaths...

But voting is often the only way we can get our voice heard:
Futures Forum: VOTE!

As the Electoral Commission says:

And our local councils do matter:



What are Local Elections? | Voting Counts
.
.
.

Brexit: and fearing a very low turnout at the local elections

People are very fed up with politics - to the extent that they might not bother turning up to vote today:
2nd May local elections: death or glory? « ComRes
Polling analysis: The full extent of Britain's division brutally revealed - politics.co.uk

As covered by today's Business Insider: 

Conservatives and Labour fear 'plague on both your houses' as Brexit anger dominates local elections

Adam Payne and Adam Bienkov

Brits go to the polls for a crucial set of local elections on Thursday.
It is the first time that the country has gone to the polls since Theresa May delayed Brexit.
Candidates from the Conservatives, Labour and other parties will contest 8,200 seats.
The Conservatives are bracing themselves for huge losses.
Labour figures believe that their party will underperform.
Turnout is expected to be really low amid growing public disillusionment with Westminster.


LONDON — Both the Conservative party and Labour fear a disappointing set of results as voters go to the polls in the first major set of elections since Theresa May's decision to delay Brexit. The country will on Thursday elect candidates to 8,200 seats covering 259 councils in England and Northern Ireland. Six directly-elected mayor positions are up for grabs in regions across England, too.

For Prime Minister Theresa May and Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn, the results will provide a clear insight into how the country feels about their handling of an extremely turbulent period in British politics. Theresa May's party have been predicted to lose hundreds of councillors across the country. However, Labour fear such predictions are overstated and expect the Liberal Democrats to gain most from any collapse in Conservative support.

The polls opened at 07:00 (BST) and will close at 22:00, with most results expected to be announced in the early hours of Friday morning and continuing through until late on Friday afternoon. Here's everything you need to know.

Angry Brexiteers are set to abandon the Conservatives

The Conservatives' biggest concern is that significant numbers people who have almost always voted for them past elections are going to ditch them on Thursday out of frustration with May's handling of Brexit. Most Conservative supporters voted for the UK to leave the EU and recent opinion polls suggest that many of them have already abandoned the party over the prime minister's failure to deliver Brexit on March 29 as promised.

Robbie Lammas, a Conservative candidate in Brexit-voting Medway, southeast England, said that he hadn't had time to focus on winning new voters due to the risk of lifelong Tories refusing to back for them and instead staying at home. "We have been visiting only people we know have voted for us in the past. It's a game of holding your voters rather than getting new ones," he said, adding "apathy is a real threat — if people stay at home, Labour will win."

Lammas added that the Tories would be in even "more trouble" had Nigel Farage's Brexit Party been standing in his ward, as "so many people have said they will vote for Farage" in his conversations with lifelong Conservative voters. "There is unanimity that Brexit is a disaster in how it is handled. Farage's narrative is turning this into a debate about democracy, honesty and respect and it has worked so well."

Another Conservative candidate in the southeast said that while the local anger over the government's handling Brexit was "nowhere near" what they had been expecting, they predicted that around twenty per cent of residents who had voted for the Conservatives in the past would stay at home this time around.

"It's more traditional Tory voters who aren't going to turn out. The people the party used to be able to rely on every year. The people who you didn't even have to knock on in the past and they'd vote for you," they told Business Insider. "People who say they've voted Tory all their lives have turned around to me and said 'I'm just not going to go out and vote… I'm really sorry but I feel like I need to send out some sort of message'."

Ben Houchen, the Conservative mayor of Tees Valley in north east England, was more optimistic. He told Business Insider that while people were "angry" and "very disatisfied" with May's handling of Brexit, "I don't think we are going to go backwards. I don't think we are going to lose many if any seats. The honest answer is had we sorted out Brexit already, I think we'd be seeing some really, really positive results. I think we will still a positive local result — but it won't be as positive as it might have been."

Will Labour capitalise on Conservative losses?Dinendra Haria/SOPA 

It's not just the Conservatives who are bracing themselves for a disappointing set of results on Thursday. Although the mood within Labour is not as gloomy as it is within the Conservatives — one Tory activist told Business Insider that their party was "absolutely f*****" — Labour are not relishing the local elections either.

Corbyn's party should make big gains across the country on Thursday. However, activists do not detect that many voters who are deserting the Conservatives over Brexit are switching to Labour, meaning the party probably won't enjoy the sort of surge in council seats they might otherwise have expected at a time when the government is in such disarray.

"Local elections haven't been that kind to us in recent years and given the chaos of the government and complete mishandling of Brexit I would expect a strong showing for Labour — but it's not clear to me that what will happen," Labour MP Bridget Phillipson told Business Insider ahead of voting getting underway.

Another Labour MP added: "We should be soaring ahead [of the Conservatives] given the abject failure of the government to solve Brexit, which is a much bigger issue for the Tories than it is for Labour." They added: "Both parties [Conservatives and Labour] will be able to say they've made progress in some areas and point it some some successes but it will be pretty poor for both to be honest."

Labour is also at risk of some of its more pro-European Union supporters switching to support candidates from the anti-Brexit Liberal Democrats and The Green Party over Corbyn's refusal to explicitly back a new referendum.

Privately senior Labour sources are playing down their chances. One told Business Insider that reports that the Conservatives would suffer big losses had been overstated. "While we hope to make progress, these are going to be a tough set of elections in predominately shire and rural areas," the source said.

They added that they expected public dissatisfaction with Brexit to hurt both parties. "People are fed up of Brexit overshadowing everything, making it harder to focus on local issues like cuts to schools and the police. Brexit has made voters of all parties fed up with a bit of a 'plague on both your houses'."

They added that the Liberal Democrats could be the main winners on the night, as they regained support from their low-point at the end of the coalition government. "When these seats were last fought in 2015, it was their worst ever council performance, so they are clearly going to have a good evening," the source predicted.

Both parties fear very low turnout

Pretty much everybody you speak to about Thursday's local elections predicts one thing: turnout will be really low. Average turnout for UK local elections is around 35%. Members of Parliament and activists across all the political parties believe that it will probably be lower than this time, due to swathes of Brits feeling so disillusioned.

The Labour Party has long faced a bigger challenge in getting their supporters to vote compared to the Conservatives. However, swathes of pro-Leave voters who have previously backed the Conservatives but intend to ditch them this time around are more than likely to stay at home and not vote at all. That's because in many regions, there isn't a pro-Leave party for disenchanted Tory supporters to go to, with UKIP contesting a limited number of seats, and Farage's Brexit Party not contesting the local elections at all.

The seats you should keep an eye on

Not every council seat in the country is being contested today. For example, there will be no action in London, Scotland, and Wales, as these regions adhere to a different local elections cycle...

Our Brexit Insider Facebook group is the best place for up-to-date news and analysis about Britain's departure from the EU, direct from Business Insider's political reporters. Join here.

How Brexit anger could cost the Conservatives and Labour in the UK local elections - Business Insider
.
.
.

Wednesday, 1 May 2019

Sidmouth Town and District council elections > tomorrow: Thursday 2nd May > "The local battle is largely between Conservatives and independents, so keep an eye on that."

There has been a lot of comment about how well or badly-received local election candidates have been over the last weeks of canvassing and hustings:
Futures Forum: Sidmouth Town and District council elections > HUSTINGS event > "Contributing to an awareness of the upcoming elections and the importance of voting."
Futures Forum: Sidmouth Town and District council elections > "less than a week to go"

Including these comments - from independents:
Independent Councillor Susie Bond (Feniton) on her canvassing experiences | East Devon Watch
Conservatives poised to lose control of East Devon District Council tomorrow for the first time - Claire Wright

And from the New Statesman:

Results come in from East Devon, where in the parliamentary seat Claire Wright, an independent, has a fighting chance of winning ahead of the Conservatives. The local battle is largely between Conservatives and independents, so keep an eye on that. 

What to look out for in the 2019 local elections - New Statesman

And from the Conservative Home site:

ElaineT· 1 day ago·
In fact I am hoping that those who do lose their seats down here are some of the reprehensible beggars that thought they were too good to be approved and re-selected. One of them actually said 'and who do you think you are to decide on whether I can stand again'.... clearly he had no idea where the Association concerned fitted in to his position on the council!
The downside of them not being returned is losing councils... the upside is rebuilding with different attitudes. Many of these people have only ever fought elections since 2007 when the mood music for Conservatives was positive, now we have to fight. Many, many of our councillors and Associations have been out campaigning for a long time and deserve to win... but quite a few haven't.
If we are really determined to rebuild, it will involve peacetime campaigning over the summer... I hope we do a lot more of that.

LeftistTory· 1 day ago
Again I agree.
My constituency has a 22,000 Tory majority and 31 of the 36 seats on the district council. Yet branches have collapsed to the extent that the bluest area has none at all.

ElaineT· 1 day ago
I tell my people that losing branches is losing the roots and without the roots, the Tory tree will die. We nurture the roots.

ExToryAgent· 1 day ago
Then the Party needs to start funding and training professional agents again and try and reinstate the organization that worked so well before...

declutterdevon· 1 day ago
You are quite right, Elaine. Branch membership has dwindled significantly and the quality of Conservative councillors has inevitably declined. Effectively, there is no selection process: anyone can be a Tory councillor simply be being prepared to do it.
I think the big story in the locals will be the success of Independents, and I think we may see a sustained increase in their representation. Its not just at national level that people are tired of party politics. In my area, the independent councillors are far better: more intelligent, more active and often nicer.

ElaineT· 1 day ago
Independents are a huge problem, devoted to preventing development with little else to say for themselves, you are never sure what you are going to get from them. Promises of 'I promise to represent you better' is not the same as 'if elected, I would like to achieve.... this, that and the other, working with a prudent Conservative council'.

Mark_A_Oliver· 1 day ago
Epsom and Ewell Borough has been run by Epsom and Ewell Residents Association since 1937. Do they fit your Nimby independent agenda too?
Other independents like Lincolnshire Independents and Hersham/Walton Village Society have been around for years. Parties like R4GV in Guildford have started because the outlying villages have been appallingly treated by a massively incompetent Conservative council.
Its not all about opposing development. In my area of east Wiltshire you are going to see independents in 2021 (including me) because of the way that Wiltshire council treats this area, closing our recycling centres, axing our childrens services, selling off playing fields to developers and putting new ones in fields flooded half the year.
The reason Wiltshire Council does this? Because its a World Heritage site/AONB so they can't dump thousands of houses here so they are not interested precisely the opposite of your narrow focused Nimby suggestion.

ElaineT· 1 day ago
Not all of Wiltshire is a World Heritage site, is it?
In Guildford it is about Nimbism and in East Devon ditto.

Mark_A_Oliver· 1 day ago
Wiltshire Council covers a big area, about 1000 sq miles. Most of NW Wiltshire is in the AONB or Stonehenge/Avebury World Heritage sites. Marlborough is forgotten by Wiltshire Council apart from dumping on it for the reason that it cant build thousands of houses there so priority goes to Chippenham and Trowbridge.
I am quite familiar with Guildford and yes there is some anti-development feeling there. However, when 80K responses to the LP consultations are ignored. When development is geared towards profits for a Cayman Islands based investment company at Wisley and University of Surrey at the Hogs Back rather than re-generating and building more affordable housing near the town centre then you are going to get opposition. Or should those villages simply roll over and accept it.
I have a good friend who is a Guildford councillor. He has told me time and time again how he was opposed to the local plan, how it was being rammed through and he was not going to vote for it. On Thursday he voted for it. In the meantime he is making his plans to move away from the GBC area - the reason? Mass development in his area ...
If this is the sort of vote fodder hypocrite who represents the Tory party at local level then I will cheer on the likes of R4GV and GGG every inch of the way.

declutterdevon· 1 day ago
I don't think the upsurge in support for independents in East Devon is all about 'nimbyism': I'm sure they would argue that they are happy to see appropriate levels of development in suitable locations.
Its more about lack of transparency, vanity projects and incompetence. And a costly new HQ.
Even the Tory Leader of the Council has resigned from the Party and is now standing as an Independent. Their own Leader doesn't like them, it seems. 


Local elections: The Conservative/Lib Dem battlegrounds | Conservative Home
.
.
.

Sidmouth Town and District council elections > HUSTINGS event > "Contributing to an awareness of the upcoming elections and the importance of voting."

The hustings in Sidmouth went well last night:
Futures Forum: Sidmouth Town and District council elections > HUSTINGS event > political speed dating

To quote a commentator:

"I thought it was a good convivial event which achieved its purpose for voters who attended. It was good to see the candidates being engaged and convivial with each other, and all in all I think the event was worthwhile, contributing to an awareness of the upcoming elections and the importance of voting."

There is further lively comment happening on the East Devon Watch blog:
Tories no-show at Sidmouth hustings last night | East Devon Watch

The organisers of the event were at pains to contact all the candidates. 

  • All current Councillors who are standing in contested wards were contacted.
  • However some of the other candidates did not have email addresses readily available.
  • The following agents, political parties and representative groups were contacted with the request that the invitation to the hustings be passed on:
    • Devon UKIP: local agent
    • East Devon Conservative Party: office@eastdevonconservatives.org
    • East Devon Labour Party: local agent
    • East Devon Liberal Democrats: info@eastdevonlibdems.org.uk
    • Independent East Devon Alliance: info@eastdevonalliance.com
    • Sid Valley Democracy: sidvalleydem@gmail.com
  • Otherwise, letters of invitation were sent to those with no such contact address or party/group affiliation.
  • The following candidates sent in their apologies:
    • Stuart Hughes (District Conservative; Town Independent)
    • Ian McKenzie Edwards (Town)
    • Louise Thompson (Town Independent)
    • Jenny Ware (District Conservative; Town Independent)
  • Otherwise, several candidates did not attend or send in apologies, despite their agents, political parties and representative groups being contacted.

Here is more information about the candidates:
Futures Forum: Sidmouth Town and District council elections > HUSTINGS event > Tuesday 30th April > candidates' manifestos

Finally, it was noted that several members of the public popped into the Hall to 'have a look' but did not want to venture in - feeling either that 'there was no point in voting' or that 'all politicians are corrupt/useless/a waste of time'...

Let's hope that voters do nevertheless turn up tomorrow on voting day:
East Devon Elections – Why go to the Hustings? - Vision Group for Sidmouth
Futures Forum: Sidmouth Town and District council elections > HUSTINGS event > Tuesday 30th April > meet the candidates in one-on-one Q&A sessions
.
.
.

Calling on the government to produce a Rural Strategy

There has been a Lords report on coastal towns:
Futures Forum: Regenerating Seaside Towns > parliamentary committee report: they need to "reinvent themselves with a long-term, place-based vision."
Futures Forum: Regenerating Seaside Towns: parliamentary committee calls for evidence > Vision Group submits report

We now have a Lords report on the rural economy - after lobbying for a rural strategy by the likes of the Rural Services Network:
Futures Forum: "Rural inequality is not just a matter for rural dwellers."
Futures Forum: How prevalent is income inequality in rural areas?
Futures Forum: Council tax rises are "the highest in rural areas"
Futures Forum: Keeping bank branches open alleviates financial exclusion

The RSN have been pushing in particular for a 'rural strategy':
Futures Forum: It's time for a Rural Strategy > conference Friday 8th March

Here's their latest piece:

LORDS RURAL ECONOMY REPORT BACKS RURAL STRATEGY CALLS

The Lords Rural Economy report, published on Saturday, was covered in a range of publications, including: ITV, ISP Review, Christian Today and Farming UK.
The report echoes RSN’s call for a comprehensive rural strategy, as argued for by chief executive Graham Biggs in an article published in The MJ today. 
It recommends that the Government rethinks and reforms the rural proofing process to ensure that relevant policies and legislation are attuned to the needs of rural communities and rural economies.
Lord Foster of Bath, chair of the Committee, commented:
‘Rural communities and the economies in them have been ignored and underrated for too long. We must act now to reverse this trend, but we can no longer allow the clear inequalities between the urban and rural to continue unchecked. A rural strategy would address challenges and realise potential in struggling and under-performing areas, and allow vibrant and thriving areas to develop further. Doing nothing is not an option.’
Full articles:
We call on Government to produce a Rural Strategy to set out their priorities for Englands Rural Communities and the Rural Economy for the future and we ask you to support this call.


.
Lords Rural Economy report backs rural strategy calls - Rural Services Network
RSN response to the House of Lords Select Committee on the Rural Economy - Rural Services Network
.
.